• Home
  • Developments Blog
  • Experience and Approach
    • Qualified Plans
    • Health and Welfare Plans
    • Fiduciary Duties
    • Executive Compensation
  • Pricing
  • About dw
  • Contact Us
    • Send a Note

Quarterly Report

8/11/2014

 
Every quarter, I prepare a recap of developments in the benefits and compensation areas for Institutional Investment Consulting.  Although many of the items have been reported in previous blog entries, I do a deeper dive for the IIC report.  Below is a copy of the most recent report, covering April through June. 
 

Bankruptcy Fairness and Employee Benefits Protection Bill and Retiree Health Vesting

6/23/2014

 
We keep track of proposed legislation that may affect employers' future plans, even though most proposed legislation either goes nowhere or has several cycles as "proposed" before it gets passed.

The above Bill (which has both bankruptcy and non-bankruptcy benefits proposals) introduced earlier in the month is in this category.  For companies in bankruptcy, it would toughen the standard for eliminating certain kinds of benefits (the changes would need to be the "minimum necessary to prevent liquidation" instead of simply "necessary to permit reorganization" and changes for rank and file employees would need to apply to officers and directors).

The more important change to watch relates to retiree medical.  The bill would create a presumption that those benefits were vested when someone has completed 20 years of service or retired.  The presumption could only be rebutted by "clear and convincing evidence" that the plan terms permitted the benefits to be eliminated AND that the participant was apprised of that fact before becoming a participant.

I'm not concerned yet, but note that this is at least the second time in recent memory that Congress has considered limits on an employer's ability to eliminate retiree medical (the Supreme Court is looking at the question in the collectively bargained context, as reported elsewhere in this blog).  Employers that are considering changes to or terminations of retiree medical coverage may want to evaluate the timeframe for that action, in case one of the legislative efforts gets some traction.  


 

Supreme Court Will Review Yard-Man Retiree Medical Inference

5/12/2014

 
The trend over at least the past decade has been toward eliminating retiree medical plans or shifting their cost to employees.  Making that kind of change has been especially difficult where those benefits were established as a result of bargaining with a union, because of the possibility that the bargained benefits were vested and, therefore, not changeable by the employer.  Under the so-called Yard-Man inference, in the Sixth Circuit, there is an inference that bargained retiree medical benefits are vested unless there is clear language rebutting that inference.  Other Circuits do not apply that inference.

The U.S. Supreme Court will consider whether there should be such an inference, in the case of M&G Polymers v. Tackett.  The decision being reviewed found that retiree benefits were vested (so, the company could not begin to charge retirees for coverage).  Cert. was granted last week, but a decision is not expected until the 2014-15 term.

 

    What You'll Find in this Blog

    Every day, I come in contact with several developments in compensation and benefits.  When I see something that is important in its own right, or that could affect decisions you make in your job, I'll post it here.  I'm not trying to give you every detail--there are other sources you can get that from, if you need it--I just want to make sure that you are aware of what's happening and what I think the implications of the development could be.

    Archives

    June 2014
    May 2014

    Categories

    All
    Affordable Care Act
    Church Plans
    Defined Contribution Plans
    Executive Compensation
    Fiduciary Duties
    Health And Welfare Plans
    Retiree Medical
    Retirement Plans

    RSS Feed


Picture
dweiner@davidweinerlegal.com

614 Academy Drive
Northbrook, IL 60062

847.604.0570 (direct)
847.919.6818 (fax)
847.561.0924 (mobile)